Skip to content
Girlfriends AI
Alex MorganBy Alex MorganUpdated

Candy AI vs Secrets AI: Which AI Companion Is Better in 2027?

Candy AI is the better value for most readers: its yearly plan costs less than half of Secrets AI Premium, and it adds an iPhone app and a refund window. Secrets AI has the deeper memory system, story formats and group chats, at a higher price. We tested both on paid plans and rechecked their pages and user reviews in November 2026.

Verdict: Choose Candy AI if you want a low yearly price, voice conversations and a 24-hour refund window. Choose Secrets AI if you want detailed memory, a daily free allowance, story formats and group chats.

Candy AI vs Secrets AI Comparison Table

Secrets AI wins more feature rows. Candy AI wins the price rows by a wide margin, plus the app and refund rows.

Candy AI vs Secrets AI Comparison Table
CategoryCandy AITested hands-onSecrets AITested hands-on
Yearly plan€47.88 (€3.99/month)Premium $109.99 ($9.17/month)
Monthly plan€9.99 first month, then €13.99Premium $19.99 on sale; $39.99 regular
Free tierUp to 5 messages20 messages a day plus 200 bonus Moments
Included currency100 tokens/month, costs not published8,000 Moments/month, costs published
MemoryMemory retention, no details publishedAutomatic memory, Smart Mode, lorebooks
VoiceVoice conversations and voice notesAudio calls at 50 Moments a minute
Video generationAI-generated videosVideo from generated images
Group chatsNot published2-3 companions on Ultimate
Mobile appiPhone app plus browserBrowser app you can install (PWA)
Payment methodsCard, Pay by BankVisa, Mastercard, Discover, 300+ cryptocurrencies
Refunds24 hours (14 days EU/UK)Billing errors only; 14 days EU/UK
Bank statementShows as EverAIShows as S LABS INC.

Winner

Yearly plan
Candy AILess than half the yearly price
Monthly plan
Candy AILower monthly price
Free tier
Secrets AIDaily free allowance
Included currency
Secrets AIPublishes what credits buy
Memory
Secrets AIDocumented memory system
Voice
TieBoth offer spoken conversations
Video generation
TieBoth include video
Group chats
Secrets AIOnly Secrets AI lists group chats
Mobile app
Candy AIHas an App Store listing
Payment methods
Secrets AIMore payment options
Refunds
Candy AIRefund window for everyone
Bank statement
TieNeither shows the app name

Price is the headline gap. Candy AI’s yearly plan costs €47.88. Secrets AI Premium costs $109.99 billed yearly, and Ultimate costs $319.99 a year. On monthly billing, Candy AI renews at €13.99, while Secrets AI Premium showed $19.99 during its November sale against a $39.99 regular price, and the wiki says sale prices apply only to the first billing period.

Secrets AI earns its rows with documentation. It publishes what its credits buy (images from 50 Moments, audio calls at 50 Moments a minute, a custom character for 500 Moments), how its memory saves and ranks facts, and which plan unlocks group chats. Candy AI publishes far less on each of those points.

Several rows end level. Both offer spoken conversations and video, and both bill under a company name instead of the app’s. On voice, Secrets AI’s calls cost Moments per minute, while Candy AI includes voice conversations in Premium without publishing a per-minute charge. On payment, Secrets AI takes Visa, Mastercard, Discover, virtual debit cards and more than 300 cryptocurrencies, and Candy AI takes cards and Pay by Bank.

Score: Candy AI 4 wins · Secrets AI 5 wins · 3 ties

Who Should Choose Candy AI, and Who Should Choose Secrets AI?

Decide by budget first. If the price gap does not bother you, Secrets AI offers more control over memory and story. If it does, Candy AI covers the core companion experience for less.

Choose Candy AI if

  • you want the lowest yearly price for unlimited chat
  • you want an iPhone app from the App Store
  • you want 24 hours to request a refund
  • you prefer a short first month at €9.99
  • you already use Discord or Twitter to log in elsewhere
Try Candy AI

Choose Secrets AI if

  • you want 20 free messages every day without paying
  • you care about a memory system you can see working
  • you like story formats such as Secret Shorts and Scenarios
  • you want group chats with two or three companions
  • you want to pay with cryptocurrency
Try Secrets AI

Candy AI suits a reader who wants one companion, unlimited chat and some media without a large bill. Its Premium covers unlimited text, 18+ images and videos and 100 tokens a month. Secrets AI suits a reader who treats the companion as a long-running story and will pay for memory, longer messages and premium chat models. If you already compared Candy AI with a catalogue-heavy rival in our Joi AI vs Candy AI breakdown, Secrets AI sits at the other end: fewer browsing tools, more depth in a single relationship.

What Is Candy AI?

Tested hands-on

Candy AI is an adults-only companion chat app from EverAI Limited in Malta, built around pre-made and custom characters with voice, images and video.

You can start with prebuilt characters or design one by choosing ethnicity, hairstyle, voice and personality traits, which needs Premium. Candy AI offers voice notes and voice conversations, AI images and AI videos, and says the companion “learns what you like, remembers what matters,” without publishing how. Premium includes unlimited text, 18+ images and videos and 100 tokens a month.

It works in desktop and mobile browsers and through an iPhone app. You get 5 messages before Candy AI asks you to subscribe. In our testing, roleplay held together well, though replies could repeat during long sessions.

Candy AI screenshot 1

Known for

  • low yearly price
  • voice conversations
  • iPhone app
Try Candy AI

What Is Secrets AI?

Tested hands-on

Secrets AI is an 18+ companion platform from Secret Labs Inc. in Dover, Delaware, with chat, a documented memory system, image and video generation, audio calls and story formats.

The free tier gives 20 messages a day and 200 bonus Moments to new accounts. Premium adds unlimited messages, 8,000 Moments a month, the S5 chat model, video generation, lorebooks, 1,000-character messages and a larger memory reach. Ultimate adds 15,000 Moments, Max thinking, 2,000-character messages, proactive messages, personas and group chats with two or three companions.

Beyond chat, Secrets AI offers Secret Shorts (episodic mini-dramas), Scenarios and Reels that open a story you continue in chat, and Time Travel to rewind a conversation. It runs in the browser and installs as a web app; its wiki says any Secrets AI listing on an app store is not affiliated with the company.

Secrets AI’s store claims more than 500 million messages sent and 50 million images and videos generated. Its memory system sets it apart from cheaper apps: Smart Mode shows a “thinking...” indicator while it searches earlier chats, so you can see recall at work.

Known for

  • memory system
  • Secret Shorts and Scenarios
  • group chats on Ultimate
Try Secrets AI

Candy AI vs Secrets AI Pricing Compared

Candy AI costs less on every term. Secrets AI gives a bigger, better-documented credit allowance.

Candy AI

1 month
€9.99 first, then €13.99
12 months
€47.88 (€3.99/month)
Free tier
Up to 5 messages
Monthly credits
100 tokens
Top-ups
Pack prices not published

Secrets AI

1 month
$19.99 sale; $39.99 regular
12 months
$109.99 ($9.17/month)
Free tier
20 messages a day, 200 bonus Moments
Monthly credits
8,000 Moments
Top-ups
4,000 Moments for $11.99 (example), 10% bonus

Secrets AI ran a “up to 77% off” sale when we checked in November 2026. Its wiki says sale prices cover the first billing period and the plan then renews at the regular price, so a monthly Premium subscriber should expect $39.99 from the second month. Candy AI also discounts the first month, from €13.99 to €9.99, and both numbers appear on its subscriptions page.

Credits work differently. Secrets AI lists Moment costs: images start at 50 Moments, audio calls cost 50 Moments a minute, and a custom character costs 500 Moments after the first free one. At those rates, Premium’s 8,000 Moments cover about 160 minutes of calls or up to 160 basic images a month. Monthly grants reset without rollover, while purchased top-ups do not expire. Candy AI includes 100 tokens a month and unlimited text but does not publish what an image or video costs in tokens.

A yearly comparison shows the size of the gap. Candy AI’s yearly plan costs €47.88. Secrets AI Premium yearly costs $109.99, and Ultimate yearly costs $319.99. Paid monthly at regular prices after the sale month, Premium would cost $459.88 for a year ($19.99 plus eleven months at $39.99), against €163.88 for Candy AI on its monthly plan. Secrets AI asks you to pay for memory depth, longer messages and premium models; Candy AI asks you to accept less documentation.

The free tiers also differ. Secrets AI’s 20 messages a day reset daily and are tied to your device, and custom characters on the free tier cap at 100 messages. Free users get the S3 and X-3 chat modes, basic memory and 500-character messages, and cannot buy Moments. Candy AI’s 5 free messages are a one-time preview.

Refunds favor Candy AI. It accepts requests within 24 hours of payment, or 14 days in the EU and UK, as long as you have used 20 tokens or fewer. Secrets AI offers no partial refunds for unused days, refunds billing errors reported within 30 days, treats Moments as final, never refunds crypto purchases, and gives EU and UK users a 14-day withdrawal right on the first purchase.

Features Compared: Candy AI vs Secrets AI

Secrets AI wins on memory, chat controls and story formats. Candy AI wins on simplicity and how much you get per euro.

Conversation quality and realism

Candy AI pairs unlimited text with voice conversations. Characters held their persona in our roleplay sessions, but replies could repeat during long chats, a complaint Reddit users share.

Secrets AI lets you choose chat models (S3, S5, S4 on Ultimate and the X-3 beta), set a thinking level from Off to Max, pick SMS or paragraph format and adjust a Spice Level for tone. Paid tiers raise the message length to 1,000 or 2,000 characters. Trustpilot reviewers mostly praise the conversations, with one saying “they remember everything.”

Verdict: Secrets AI. Model, thinking and tone controls let you shape replies.

Memory and context retention

Candy AI promises memory retention but publishes no size, controls or rules.

Secrets AI saves facts from your chat automatically and ranks them as high, medium or low importance. Its Smart Mode searches saved memories and past conversations before replying, shown by a “thinking...” indicator. Premium accesses four times as many memories with 60% more context, Ultimate six times with double the context, and both add lorebooks for world details.

If you cancel Secrets AI, its wiki says your chats, memories, custom characters and media stay in the account and you drop to the free tier, so you can return later without starting over. Candy AI says the account reverts to the free version when paid access ends, but does not spell out what happens to memory.

Verdict: Secrets AI, by a wide margin.

Character creation and customization

Candy AI’s builder covers ethnicity, hairstyle, voice and personality traits, with prebuilt characters available on every plan. Custom creation needs Premium.

Secrets AI says over a million companions are available and lets you create custom characters, with the first one free and each later one costing 500 Moments. Ultimate adds custom personality editing, personas and persona photos.

Verdict: Tie. Candy AI includes unlimited custom companions in Premium; Secrets AI offers deeper editing on Ultimate.

Voice, images and multimedia

Candy AI includes voice notes, voice conversations, personalized images and AI videos, with 18+ images and videos inside Premium.

Secrets AI generates images in its Studio, with an Ultra image model as the default, and turns generated images into video on paid plans. Audio calls cost 50 Moments a minute, follow your Spice Level and are transcribed in real time with the audio deleted afterward. Group voice calls are in beta. You cannot upload your own images; all media is AI-generated.

Verdict: Tie. Secrets AI documents costs and privacy for calls; Candy AI bundles voice and media into a cheaper plan.

Roleplay and creative scenarios

Candy AI advertises a wide variety of roleplay scenarios under fictional, consenting rules, and its characters held scenes in our testing.

Secrets AI builds roleplay into formats: Secret Shorts are episodic mini-dramas, Scenarios and Reels open a story you continue in chat, Time Travel lets you rewind and try another path, and Ultimate supports group chats with two or three companions.

Proactive Messaging on Ultimate lets a companion message you first, which suits readers who want the relationship to feel two-sided. Candy AI waits for you to open the chat.

Verdict: Secrets AI for structured stories and group scenes.

Content controls and filters

Candy AI asks users to affirm they are 18 or older and keeps content inside fictional, consenting roleplay, without publishing moderation steps.

Secrets AI publishes a Prohibited Content Policy, a Content Moderation policy, pre- and post-screening rules and a Safety Guidelines page. It scans every input in real time, classifies outputs and sends flags to human review. It bans child sexual content, non-consensual sexual acts even in fiction, sexual content of real people and trafficking outright.

Verdict: Secrets AI. Its rules and checks are documented.

Fetish requests

Candy AI supports adult roleplay and media but publishes no kink list.

Secrets AI’s Spice Level adjusts tone. Its policy bans non-consensual sexual acts and real-person sexual content outright, and lists themes such as extreme violence, zoophilia and necrophilia as context-dependent, without saying how it rules on each. It does not publish an accepted-kink list either.

Verdict: Tie. Secrets AI publishes clearer limits; neither publishes what it allows in detail.

Signup & Log in Process Compared

Both sign-ups are short. Secrets AI greets new accounts with 200 free Moments.

Signup & Log in Process Compared
StepCandy AISecrets AI
1Click Create Free AccountOpen secrets.ai and pass the 18+ gate
2Choose email, Twitter, Google or DiscordChoose Google, Apple or email
3Confirm your email if promptedClaim 200 bonus Moments
4Affirm you are 18 or olderPick a companion or scenario
5Choose a character and chatChat; 20 free messages a day
Log in withEmail, Twitter, Google, DiscordGoogle, Apple, email
NoteUse the same provider each timeFree messages are tied to your device

Secrets AI also gives 25 extra Moments once if you turn on notifications. Candy AI records your signup provider, so use the same one to get back into your history.

User Reviews and Reputation

Secrets AI’s public reviews lean positive with price complaints. Candy AI’s lean negative on billing, with praise for its writing.

Candy AI.

Candy AI’s Reddit threads split between praise for the language model and complaints about repetitive replies. PissedConsumer reviews focus on billing disputes and extra paywalls. The Candy AI review lists dated quotes from each platform.

Secrets AI.

Secrets AI’s Trustpilot page showed 4.5 from 332 reviews when we checked. One reviewer upgraded to Ultimate “because I was having so much fun engaging with the companions and creating new ones,” another calls it “kind of expensive but for the experience its ok,” and a 1-star review says only “This app is not good.”

Privacy and Safety: Candy AI vs Secrets AI

Secrets AI publishes more about encryption and deletion. Both keep the product name off your bank statement.

Candy AI names EverAI Limited in Malta, uses TLS 1.2 or higher in transit, processes your chat inputs and the AI’s outputs, and lets you request deletion of personal data. Charges show as EverAI.

Secrets AI’s privacy policy describes AES-256 encryption at rest, TLS 1.2 or higher in transit and role-based access. It deletes personal data and chat history on account deletion, keeps transaction records for seven years and security logs for up to 12 months, and says it does not sell personal information. It uses data to train and improve its models. Its homepage mentions end-to-end encryption, but the privacy policy does not describe end-to-end encryption. Charges show as S LABS INC.

Ease of Use and Platform Experience

Candy AI is quicker to learn: choose a character, chat, call or request media, with one Premium tier and one token balance. It runs in the browser and as an iPhone app.

Secrets AI has more settings to learn, including chat models, thinking levels, Spice Level, message format, memory importance and Moments costs. It runs in the browser and installs as a web app on your phone’s home screen. Once set up, the wiki documents each feature in plain steps, which helps.

Neither service has an Android app. Candy AI’s iPhone app needs iOS 16 or later. Secrets AI’s installable web app works on both iPhone and Android home screens, and its wiki warns that app-store listings under its name are not affiliated with it.

If you want to start chatting with no learning curve, Candy AI is easier. If you enjoy tuning how a companion thinks and remembers, Secrets AI gives you the knobs.

How We Compared Them

Our testing ran two to three months per service on paid plans, at a cost of $500 to $3,000 per app. In November 2026 we rechecked store pages, wiki and help articles, policies and public reviews.

  1. Chat and memory. Persona consistency, recall over weeks and the controls each app gives you.
  2. Price per term. Monthly and yearly plans, sale versus renewal prices and credit costs.
  3. Features. Voice calls, image and video tools, Shorts and Scenarios, and group chats.
  4. Rules and billing. Moderation, refunds, payment methods and statement names.
  5. User sentiment. Repeated themes on Trustpilot, Reddit and PissedConsumer.

Other Alternatives

Readers weighing price against memory can also look at the Candy AI alternatives we tested.

Joi AI

Score: 9.8/10

Joi AI publishes 8,000-message smart memory on Premium and costs $47.99 a year. Romantic messages and some media use Neurons.

Check it out: Joi AI

Candy AI vs Secrets AI FAQs

  1. Is Secrets AI more expensive than Candy AI?

    Yes. Secrets AI Premium costs $109.99 a year or $39.99 a month at regular price ($19.99 during its sale), while Candy AI costs €47.88 a year or €13.99 a month after a €9.99 first month.

  2. Does Secrets AI have a free plan?

    Yes. Free accounts get 20 messages a day tied to the device and 200 bonus Moments at sign-up. Candy AI gives free accounts 5 messages in total.

  3. Which has better memory?

    Secrets AI. It saves facts automatically, ranks them by importance, searches past chats in Smart Mode and adds lorebooks on paid plans. Candy AI does not document its memory.

  4. Is there a Secrets AI app?

    No store app. Secrets AI installs from the browser as a web app, and its wiki warns that any app-store listing is not affiliated with it. Candy AI has an iPhone app.

  5. How do Candy AI and Secrets AI appear on a card statement?

    Secrets AI charges show as S LABS INC., and Candy AI charges show as EverAI. Neither names the app.

  6. Can I get a refund?

    Candy AI accepts requests within 24 hours (14 days in the EU and UK) if you used 20 tokens or fewer. Secrets AI refunds only billing errors within 30 days, plus the EU and UK 14-day withdrawal right, and never refunds crypto.

Our pick

Candy AI

Try Candy AI