Skip to content
Girlfriends AI
Alex MorganBy Alex MorganUpdated

Joi AI vs Secrets AI: Which AI Companion Is Better in 2027?

Joi AI is the better pick for most paying readers: Premium costs $13.99 a month or $47.99 a year, well under Secrets AI’s $19.99 and $109.99, and it offers video calls where available plus multi-user group chats. Secrets AI has the stronger free tier, at 20 messages a day, plus story formats and detailed memory tools. We tested both on paid plans and checked their pricing, help and policy pages in November 2026.

Verdict: Choose Joi AI if you want the lower price, voice and video calls and group chats without a top tier. Choose Secrets AI if you want daily free chat, story-driven Shorts and Scenarios, and memory you can tune.

Joi AI vs Secrets AI Comparison Table

Joi AI wins four rows, Secrets AI three, and five end in ties, so the result rests on price and calling. Joi AI costs $13.99 a month against $19.99 and $47.99 a year against $109.99, and it offers video calls where available and group chats without a higher tier. Secrets AI pulls back on free use, with 20 messages a day and 200 bonus Moments, and on story formats and published data security. Note that Secrets AI’s store showed a Black Friday sale when we checked, with Premium’s $19.99 monthly price set against a crossed-out $39.99, and its wiki says sale prices apply to the first billing period only.

Joi AI vs Secrets AI Comparison Table
CategoryJoi AITested hands-onSecrets AITested hands-on
Price, 1 month$13.99$19.99
Price, 12 months$47.99 a year$109.99 a year
Free tierBasic, 6 lifetime images20 messages a day, 200 bonus Moments
Included currency1,000 to 1,500 Neurons a month8,000 Moments a month
Memory8,000-message smart memoryMemory system, Smart Mode, Lorebooks
Voice and video callsVoice chat, video calls where availableAudio calls at 50 Moments a minute
Video generationAI video creationVideo from generated images
Group chatsMulti-user group chats on the platform2-3 companions, Ultimate only
Story formatsCharacter chatSecret Shorts, Scenarios and Reels
RefundsCase-based within 14 daysEU/UK 14 days, billing errors 30 days
Bank statementjoi.comS LABS INC.
Data securityNot sold; no encryption standard namedAES-256 at rest, TLS 1.2+, instant deletion

Winner

Price, 1 month
Joi AI$6 less a month
Price, 12 months
Joi AILess than half the yearly bill
Free tier
Secrets AIFree chat every day
Included currency
TieUnits differ, so the counts don’t compare
Memory
TieBoth document memory well
Voice and video calls
Joi AIAdds video calls
Video generation
TieBoth generate clips
Group chats
Joi AINo top tier needed
Story formats
Secrets AIGuided story openings
Refunds
TieBoth narrow, both written down
Bank statement
TieBoth discreet
Data security
Secrets AIMore detailed security

Score: Joi AI 4 wins · Secrets AI 3 wins · 5 ties

Who Should Choose Joi AI, and Who Should Choose Secrets AI?

Choose by budget and by how you like to start a chat: from a character, or from a story.

Choose Joi AI if

  • you want the lowest monthly or yearly price of the two
  • you plan to use voice chat and video calls where available
  • you want group chats without paying for a higher tier
  • you like browsing Joi Originals, celebrity and community characters
  • you want a stated memory size of 8,000 messages
Try Joi AI

Choose Secrets AI if

  • you want to chat free every day before paying
  • you like starting from episodic Shorts or Scenarios instead of a blank chat
  • you want to tune memory with importance levels and Lorebooks
  • you care about AES-256 encryption and immediate deletion
  • you pay with crypto or a virtual debit card
Try Secrets AI

Joi AI suits readers who want a character-first companion with several ways to talk; our Joi AI review covers Neurons and Premium in detail. Secrets AI suits readers who want story and memory controls, and the Secrets AI review explains its chat modes and Moments. Don’t confuse Secrets AI with Secret Desires AI, a separate product.

What Is Joi AI?

Tested hands-on

Joi AI is an adults-only AI companion platform for chat, voice, video calls, image and video creation, and custom characters, with Premium plus Neurons for extras.

The catalogue mixes Joi Originals, official digital duplicates of celebrities and community-made characters, with filters such as Girls, Guys, Trans, Anime and Kinky. You can talk by text or voice, use the Video Call Feature where your device, region and plan allow, send images in chat, make images in the Gallery creator and generate AI video. Comments and multi-user group chats add a social side.

Basic is free with limited access and 6 lifetime image generations. Premium adds monthly Neurons, larger image and video allowances, Smart Memory and priority creation. Neurons also pay for romantic or explicit messages outside the subscription, which is the main cost catch. Novi Limited in Cyprus is the data controller. In our testing, characters stayed in character well, though some users report slow scene pacing.

Joi AI screenshot 1

Known for

  • video calls
  • celebrity characters
  • 8,000-message memory
Try Joi AI

What Is Secrets AI?

Tested hands-on

Secrets AI is an adults-only AI companion platform at secrets.ai with story-led Shorts and Scenarios, a detailed memory system, image and video generation and audio calls paid in Moments.

Secrets AI offers several ways in. Secret Shorts are episodic mini-dramas, Scenarios and Reels open a story you continue in chat, and you can also pick a companion or build a custom character. Chat modes (S3, S5, S4 and an X-3 beta) and thinking levels change how replies read, and a Spice Level setting controls tone. The memory system saves facts automatically with high, medium or low importance, and Smart Mode searches memories and past chats before it replies.

Secret Labs Inc. in Dover, Delaware runs Secrets AI. Free accounts get 20 messages a day and 200 bonus Moments at sign-up. Premium adds unlimited messages, 8,000 Moments a month, video generation and Lorebooks; Ultimate adds group chats, personas and proactive messages. There is no app store app: you install a web app from the browser, and the wiki warns that Secrets AI apps listed on app stores are not connected to the company.

Known for

  • Secret Shorts
  • memory with importance levels
  • 20 free messages a day
Try Secrets AI

Joi AI vs Secrets AI Pricing Compared

Joi AI costs less on every comparable term. Secrets AI gives you more free use and a bigger monthly currency grant.

Joi AI

Free
Basic, 6 lifetime image generations
1 month
$13.99
3 months
$20.99
12 months
$47.99
Monthly currency
1,000 to 1,500 Neurons
Statement shows
joi.com

Secrets AI

Free
20 messages a day, 200 bonus Moments
1 month
Premium $19.99, Ultimate $39.99
3 months
Not published
12 months
Premium $109.99, Ultimate $319.99
Monthly currency
8,000 Moments (15,000 on Ultimate)
Statement shows
S LABS INC.

On the monthly term, Joi AI’s Premium costs $13.99 and Secrets AI’s Premium $19.99. On the yearly term, Joi AI costs $47.99 and Secrets AI $109.99, or $9.17 a month. Joi AI also sells a 3-month plan at $20.99; Secrets AI does not list one. Secrets AI’s store showed a sale when we checked, and its wiki says sale prices apply to the first billing period only before the plan renews at the regular price, so check the renewal price at checkout.

The currencies cover different things. Joi AI’s Neurons pay for content outside the subscription: 4 Neurons to read a romantic message, up to 120 to view a photo and up to 1,900 for a video, with packs from $9.99 for 500. Secrets AI’s Moments pay for images (from 50 Moments), video, audio calls (50 a minute) and custom characters (500 Moments, first one free), and a 4,000-Moment top-up costs $11.99. Secrets AI’s grants reset monthly with no rollover; Joi AI’s help center says unused monthly benefits roll over.

Refund rules are narrow on both. Joi AI considers refund requests within 14 days in listed cases. Secrets AI gives no partial refunds for unused days, handles billing errors within 30 days, treats Moments as final and never refunds crypto purchases, with a 14-day withdrawal right for EU and UK first purchases.

A year of each makes the gap concrete. Joi AI’s 12-month Premium costs $47.99 and grants 1,500 Neurons a month. Secrets AI’s yearly Premium costs $109.99 and grants 8,000 Moments a month, enough for 160 minutes of audio calls at 50 a minute if you spent them all on calls. Paying month to month for a year, Joi AI costs $167.88 and Secrets AI $239.88 at the listed $19.99. Ultimate on Secrets AI adds $20 a month on monthly billing, or $14.17 a month on yearly billing, for group chats and personas.

Verdict: Joi AI. It costs $6 less a month and $62 less a year. Secrets AI is worth the extra if daily free chat and a large Moments grant matter more than price.

Features Compared: Joi AI vs Secrets AI

Joi AI wins two of the seven areas, Secrets AI one, and four end level. Joi AI’s wins come from calls and its character builder; Secrets AI’s from story formats.

Conversation quality and realism

Joi AI. Joi AI supports text, voice and, where available, real-time video calls. In our testing characters stayed in character well, though some users call scene pacing slow or scripted.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI lets you switch chat modes and thinking levels, set a Spice Level, and choose SMS or paragraph style. Trustpilot reviewers rate it 4.5 from 332 reviews, with some praising the companions and one calling it “kind of expensive.”

Verdict: tie. Joi AI gives you more ways to talk; Secrets AI gives you more control over how replies read.

Memory and context retention

Joi AI. Premium includes 8,000-message smart memory, and you can use Reset Memory in chat settings. Users still report forgetting after long gaps.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI saves facts automatically with importance levels, searches memories in Smart Mode, and adds Lorebooks on paid plans. Ultimate increases memories accessed and context. One Trustpilot reviewer wrote, “They remember everything.”

Verdict: tie. Joi AI publishes a size; Secrets AI publishes more tools.

Character creation and customization

Joi AI. Joi AI’s builder covers looks, personality, behavior and kinks, and the catalogue includes Joi Originals, celebrities and community characters.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI lets you create custom characters for 500 Moments, with the first one free, and Ultimate adds personas and custom personality editing. Its sign-up screen claims over 1,000,000 AI companions.

Verdict: Joi AI. Its builder and catalogue come with Premium, while Secrets AI charges Moments per character and keeps deeper editing on Ultimate.

Voice, images and multimedia

Joi AI. Joi AI offers voice chat, video calls where available, image sending in chat, a Gallery image creator with up to 12 images per run, and AI video generation.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI offers image generation from 50 Moments, video generation from generated images, and audio calls at 50 Moments a minute. It transcribes call audio in real time and deletes the audio, keeping only the transcript. It does not offer video calls, and you cannot upload your own images.

Verdict: Joi AI. Video calls and image uploads in chat give it the wider media set.

Roleplay and creative scenarios

Joi AI. Joi AI advertises adult roleplay on Premium, and its homepage says virtual models learn your likes, kinks and fantasies. Some romantic or explicit messages cost Neurons.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI builds roleplay into its formats: Shorts play out as mini-dramas, Scenarios and Reels hand you an opening to continue, Time Travel lets you rewind a chat, and Ultimate adds group chats with 2 or 3 companions.

Verdict: Secrets AI. Guided openings and rewind tools give scene writers more structure.

Fetish requests

Joi AI. Joi AI’s homepage says its virtual models learn your likes, kinks, fetish and fantasy and reflect them in NSFW chats. Its safety guidelines block topics including incest, zoophilia, necrophilia and child exploitation.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI lets you set a Spice Level and lists absolute bans on CSAM, non-consensual sexual acts even in fiction, real-person sexual content and trafficking, with zoophilia and necrophilia under context-dependent rules.

Verdict: tie. Both allow adult fantasy, and both publish clear hard limits.

Content controls and filters

Joi AI. Joi AI uses VerifyMyAge checks that can include a face scan or ID, screens every message with automated checks and a RoBERTa classifier, and checks image and video prompts before generation.

Secrets AI. Secrets AI shows an 18+ gate, scans all inputs in real time, classifies outputs, sends flags to human review, and publishes a prohibited content policy covering CSAM, non-consent, real-person deepfakes and trafficking.

Verdict: tie. Joi AI does more on age checks; Secrets AI publishes more on moderation.

Signup & Log in Process Compared

Both offer Google, Apple and email. Joi AI adds Facebook and a stronger age check.

Signup & Log in Process Compared
StepJoi AISecrets AI
1Open joi.comOpen secrets.ai and confirm you are 18+
2Choose email, Apple, Facebook or GoogleChoose Google, Apple or email
3Enter the email code if you use emailCollect 200 free Moments
4Pass an age check if Joi AI asksPick a companion, Short or Scenario
5Pick or build a character and chatStart chatting on the free tier
Log in withEmail, Apple, Facebook, GoogleGoogle, Apple, email
Note18+ only. VerifyMyAge may ask for an email check, face scan or ID.18+ only. You confirm your age at the gate.

Joi AI allows one account per user. Secrets AI ties the free daily allowance to your device, according to its wiki.

User Reviews and Reputation

Secrets AI has the stronger Trustpilot rating; Joi AI’s feedback is more mixed.

Joi AI.

Trustpilot reviewers praise ease of use, with one calling it “straight up easy to use,” while another says “the images generated are not very consistent.” A Reddit r/Chatbots user wrote that “the progression of scenes is incredibly slow, the responses feel pre-scripted, kinda robotic.” Neuron costs on top of Premium are the most common complaint.

Secrets AI.

Secrets AI holds 4.5 from 332 reviews on Trustpilot. One reviewer upgraded to Ultimate “because I was having so much fun engaging with the companions and creating new ones.” A three-star reviewer called it “kind of expensive but for the experience its ok,” and a one-star review says, “This app is not good.”

Privacy and Safety: Joi AI vs Secrets AI

Secrets AI publishes more security detail. Joi AI publishes more about age checks and has one unusual chargeback clause.

Secrets AI’s privacy policy describes AES-256 encryption at rest, TLS 1.2+ in transit and role-based access. It says it deletes personal information and chat history immediately when you delete your account, keeps transaction records for 7 years and security logs for up to 12 months, and does not sell personal information. It also uses data to train and improve its AI models. The homepage mentions end-to-end encryption, but the privacy policy does not describe it.

Joi AI’s privacy policy names Novi Limited in Cyprus as data controller and says Joi AI does not sell or rent your information, though chats may be shared with related companies and service providers, and text and voice messages help develop the AI. It does not name an encryption standard. Joi AI says it does not keep copies of your ID after age verification.

Ease of Use and Platform Experience

Joi AI is easier to pick up: choose a character and chat, with calls and the Gallery a tap away. Secrets AI has more settings to learn, from chat modes and thinking levels to Spice Level, Lorebooks and Time Travel, which reward readers who like to tweak.

Both run in the browser. Joi AI publishes help for Chrome, Edge and Firefox and supports English, German, French, Japanese, Spanish and Portuguese. Secrets AI installs as a web app from the browser, and it has no official app store listing.

Cancelling is simple on both. Joi AI cancels from Settings > My Subscriptions, effective from the next subscription month. Secrets AI cancels from Settings > Manage Subscription, keeps your access until the period ends, then moves you to the free tier with your chats, memories, custom characters and media preserved, so you can resume later.

How We Compared Them

We tested Joi AI and Secrets AI on their paid plans for two to three months each, spending between $500 and $3,000 per app, then checked each product’s store page, wiki or help center, terms and privacy policy, plus public reviews, in November 2026.

  1. Conversation and memory. We judged how well each companion held a scene and remembered details.
  2. Features. Calls, media, story formats and group chats.
  3. Pricing. Monthly and yearly prices plus what the in-app currency buys.
  4. Safety and privacy. Age checks, moderation, encryption and refunds.
  5. User sentiment. Trustpilot and Reddit themes.

Other Alternatives

Our Joi AI alternatives roundup lists more companions with different billing, and the Joi AI vs OurDream AI matchup compares Joi AI with another large catalogue.

Candy AI

Score: 9.6/10

Candy AI pairs pre-made and custom characters with voice conversations, images and video. Its 12-month plan costs €47.88, and Premium includes unlimited text.

Check it out: Candy AI

OurDream AI

Score: 9.3/10

OurDream AI offers over 11 million characters, voice calls and a published Dreamcoin rate card. Subscriber chats cost 0 Dreamcoins.

Check it out: OurDream AI

Kindroid

Score: 8.5/10

Kindroid builds around one companion with documented long-term memory, live voice and video calls and group chats. New accounts get 50 free messages.

Check it out: Kindroid

Joi AI vs Secrets AI FAQs

  1. Which is cheaper, Joi AI or Secrets AI?

    Joi AI. Premium costs $13.99 a month or $47.99 a year, against Secrets AI’s $19.99 a month or $109.99 a year. Secrets AI’s sale prices apply to the first billing period only, so check the renewal price.

  2. Which has the better free tier?

    Secrets AI. Free accounts get 20 messages a day and 200 bonus Moments. Joi AI’s Basic plan gives limited access and 6 lifetime image generations, without a published daily message count.

  3. Is Secrets AI the same as Secret Desires AI?

    No. Secrets AI runs at secrets.ai and is operated by Secret Labs Inc. Secret Desires AI is a separate product with its own review on this site.

  4. Can I video call on either app?

    Joi AI offers a Video Call Feature where your device, region and plan allow. Secrets AI offers audio calls at 50 Moments a minute but no video calls.

  5. Which one remembers more?

    Joi AI publishes 8,000-message smart memory on Premium. Secrets AI does not give a message count but saves facts by importance, searches past chats in Smart Mode and adds Lorebooks on paid plans. Both work best if you restate key details.

  6. Do they have mobile apps?

    Neither has an official App Store or Google Play app. Both run in a mobile browser, and Secrets AI can be installed as a web app.

Our pick

Joi AI

Try Joi AI